Rush Limbaugh was at it again last week. If he doesn’t cook up his own wrong math, he picks up on other people’s misleading calculations about the war in Iraq.
Last time, as noted on this page, he compared the murder rate in Philadelphia to the number of fallen US soldiers in Iraq and came to the blatantly erroneous conclusion that the casualties in Iraq are not that big a deal after all.
This time Rush picked up on a column written by Alicia Colon in the conservative New York Sun in which she compares the military casualties during Bush’s war in Iraq with the number of military death during Clinton’s peacetime years.
Here is the quote from the Sun column:
“The total military dead in the Iraq war between 2003 and this month stands at about 3,133. This is tragic, as are all deaths due to war, and we are facing a cowardly enemy unlike any other in our past that hides behind innocent citizens. Each death is blazoned in the headlines of newspapers and Internet sites. What is never compared is the number of military deaths during the Clinton administration: 1,245 in 1993; 1,109 in 1994; 1,055 in 1995; 1,008 in 1996. That’s 4,417 deaths in peacetime but, of course, who’s counting?”
Since Limbaugh’s “ditto head” listeners take most of his claims at face value, it is save to assume that few actually bothered to wonder why you would compare these two sets of numbers.
The only reason why anybody would compare peacetime military deaths (due to accidents, illness, suicide etc.) during the Clinton years to the actual combat related casualties in Iraq is to confuse the issue.
Of course, Alicia Colon’s flawed comparison didn’t fly and was quickly debunked by blogger Andrew Sullivan, Salon.com and others.
But a flawed comparison has never kept Rush Limbaugh from assuring his weekly audience of 13 millions that things are just fine over in Baghdad. Here is what he had to say:
Listen to this short MP3 clip from “The Rush Limbaugh Show” (01:18)
www.Rushbo.com gives people around the world an insight into the entertaining and sometimes brutal war of opinion in the US.